PPOR vs Investment Debt: What Australian Borrowers Should Know

PPOR debt (the loan on your principal place of residence, meaning the home you live in) is not tax-deductible. Investment debt usually is. The ATO decides this by what you used the borrowed money for, not by which property secures the loan. So the real question is not which loan is bigger, but which dollar of debt costs you more after tax, and what happens to your retirement date when you pay one down first. Modelling both side by side in AeroWealth shows that in one plan.
TL;DR
- Interest on money borrowed to buy a rental or other income-producing asset is generally deductible. Interest on money borrowed for your home is not.
- Purpose beats security: a loan secured against your home can be deductible if the funds buy an investment.
- Mixed-purpose loans must be apportioned, and every repayment is apportioned too.
- Under the 2026-27 Budget measures, losses on established residential investments bought after 12 May 2026 face limits from 1 July 2027, which changes the maths of holding investment debt.
- The right paydown order depends on your tax rate, rates, offset balances and retirement timing, so test it as scenarios rather than guess.
Table of Contents
- The core difference: what the money was used for
- Mixed-purpose loans and redraws
- Why paying off the PPOR first is not always the answer
- Debt recycling: turning home debt into investment debt
- When your home becomes a rental, or the reverse
- The 2026-27 Budget change for investment debt
- How to compare the two debts in your own numbers
- Promo: model both debts in one plan
- Our perspective
- FAQ
- Sources
The core difference: what the money was used for
The ATO’s ruling TD 93/13 sets out the principle. Interest on a loan used to buy income-producing property, such as a rental, is an allowable deduction. Interest on a loan used for private purposes, such as buying the home you live in, is not.
The security does not decide it. The same ruling gives two examples:
- Zeb owns his home outright and borrows to buy a rental, with the bank taking a mortgage over his home as security. All the money buys the rental, so all the interest is deductible.
- Debbie borrows $100,000 against her home. She spends $20,000 renovating it and $80,000 buying a rental. Only 8/10 of the interest is deductible.
This is why “PPOR debt” and “investment debt” are labels for purpose, not for which property the bank holds. Two loans at the same interest rate can have very different after-tax costs.
A worked example
Suppose you pay 6% on both a $400,000 home loan and a $400,000 investment loan, and your marginal tax rate (including the 2% Medicare levy) is 32%. Pre-tax interest is $24,000 a year on each. The home loan interest is not deductible, so it costs you $24,000. The investment loan interest is deductible, so its after-tax cost is $24,000 × (1 − 0.32) = $16,320, before counting rental income, which is taxable. The figures are illustrative, not a forecast, but they show why the home loan is the more expensive debt per dollar once you ignore the rent.

Rent changes the picture. If the rent covers the interest, there is no loss to claim and the comparison becomes about the asset’s growth against its costs. That is where scenario modelling earns its keep.
Mixed-purpose loans and redraws
Most tax trouble starts when one loan serves two purposes. The ATO’s interest expenses guidance (updated 21 May 2026) says that if a loan account is used for both private and rental purposes, you must keep accurate records and work out the rental portion. You cannot choose to repay only the private part: repayments are apportioned across both portions for the life of the loan.
Redraws follow the same logic. TR 2000/2 says:
- If the original borrowing was for a non-income purpose and you redraw funds for an income-producing purpose, the interest on that redrawn part is deductible.
- If the original borrowing was for an income purpose and you redraw for a private purpose, that part is not deductible.
- Once purposes are mixed, the account stays a mixed-purpose account and interest is apportioned on a fair and reasonable basis, with later repayments split between the income and private parts of the balance.
The practical lesson is to keep purposes in separate loan splits. Pull equity out of your home as a new, separate split used only for the investment, and the paper trail stays clean. Dropping investment money into your home loan, or using an investment redraw for a holiday, contaminates the deduction.
Why paying off the PPOR first is not always the answer
The usual rule of thumb says to clear the non-deductible debt first. It is logical: every dollar you repay on the home loan saves interest that you could never claim. Repaying deductible investment debt saves interest, but part of that saving is offset by the lost deduction.
The trade-offs that matter are:
- Cash flow. Investment loan interest reduces your taxable income, so the after-tax burden is lighter. Home loan repayments come entirely from after-tax dollars.
- Tax rate. The higher your marginal rate, the more valuable the deduction, and the more tempting it is to hold investment debt. At lower rates the deduction is worth less.
- Rental income and gearing. If the property is neutrally or positively geared, there is little or no loss to claim, so the tax advantage of keeping the debt shrinks.
- Asset growth. Debt on an asset that grows can build wealth, but growth is not guaranteed and a property you cannot afford to hold is a risk, not a strategy.
- Offset balances. Cash in an offset against the home loan cuts non-deductible interest without touching the deductible debt. Cash against the investment loan does the reverse, so where the offset sits matters. Our guide to an offset account for an investment property explains the structure.
- Retirement timing. Debt carried into retirement has to be serviced from super, rent or sale proceeds. A home loan cleared at retirement lowers the income you need.
No single order wins for everyone. A 55-year-old on a high marginal rate with a rental that is negatively geared faces a different decision than a 30-year-old with a new mortgage and no investment yet.
Debt recycling: turning home debt into investment debt
Debt recycling means using spare cash to repay the home loan, then redrawing or re-borrowing the same amount through a separate split to buy an income-producing investment. Total debt stays similar, but the non-deductible part shrinks as the deductible part grows. The ATO tests it by purpose: the borrowed money must be used to acquire the income-producing asset, and the new split must be kept clean, as covered above.
It rewards discipline and record keeping. It also adds market risk, because the investment can fall in value while the debt stays. If you are unsure how a structure applies to your circumstances, speak to a registered tax agent or licensed financial adviser before acting. Modelling it first at least shows how sensitive the result is to returns and rates.
When your home becomes a rental, or the reverse
Changing a property’s use changes the tax treatment, and debt follows.
If you move out and rent your home, interest on that loan can become deductible while it is producing income. You may also choose to keep treating it as your main residence for up to six years under section 118-145 of the ITAA 1997, provided it is used to produce income. Our guide to the six-year rule walks through the conditions.
If a rental becomes your main residence, the ATO says the main residence exemption covers only the period you lived there. For the rented period you owe capital gains tax on a proportion: the gain or loss multiplied by the days used to produce income, divided by total days owned (ATO, using your home for rental or business, 22 June 2026).
A full exemption needs the dwelling to have been your home for the whole ownership period, never used to produce income, on two hectares or less (ITAA 1997 s 118-110). For the detail, see our main residence exemption guide.
The 2026-27 Budget change for investment debt
The MFAA’s Budget summary describes a change to negative gearing. From 1 July 2027, losses on established residential investment properties bought after 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 generally cannot offset salary or other personal income. They can offset rental income or future residential capital gains, with unused losses carried forward. Eligible new builds keep access to negative gearing.
Properties owned before that time are grandfathered, so current rules continue to apply to them. Properties bought between Budget night and 30 June 2027 can still use current rules until 1 July 2027 unless they qualify as eligible new builds.
For debt decisions this matters in a specific way. If you plan to buy an established investment property now, the deduction on its interest may stop reducing your wage tax from 1 July 2027. The after-tax cost of that debt would then look closer to the cost of your home loan, which weakens the case for prioritising the investment loan. Check the final legislation and the ATO for the rules as enacted, because Budget measures can change before they become law. Our piece on the CGT discount and 1 July 2027 covers the related timing questions, and our guide to investment property tax write-offs lists what else you can claim.

How to compare the two debts in your own numbers
Follow these steps to decide your own order of repayment.
- List every loan by purpose. For each split, write down what the money bought: home, rental, shares, or a mix. Mixed splits need an apportionment.
- Note rate, balance and repayment type. Include whether it is interest-only or principal-and-interest, and what sits in each offset.
- Work out your marginal rate. Deductions are worth your marginal rate plus Medicare levy, so a wage change moves the answer.
- Estimate the property’s cash result. Rent, interest, rates, insurance and maintenance give you a gearing position, and the rule change above affects what the loss is worth.
- Pick your retirement target. Debt-free at 60 and debt-free at 67 are different plans, especially if you are retiring before preservation age and need to bridge the years before super is accessible.
- Run scenarios, not a single answer. Compare paying down the home, paying down the investment, holding cash in offset and recycling, then stress test rates and growth.
Spreadsheets can do this, but the apportionment, tax and super interactions get tangled quickly. This is where the side-by-side comparison in AeroWealth takes work off your hands: you can place your super, investment property, ETFs, mortgage and contributions in one plan and compare the scenarios against retirement age, income and net worth.
Promo: model both debts in one plan
AeroWealth is built for Australians who want to see how a decision on home or investment debt changes their retirement. You can compare scenarios side by side, stress test your assumptions, and model CGT, tax and mortgage offset strategies alongside your super. There is a Free plan, and Pro is 7 AUD per month with expanded scenario planning, bridge mode for retiring before Super preservation age, advanced mortgage features and a higher AI assistant quota. See the Free and Pro plans.

Our perspective
Debt decisions look like arithmetic and behave like strategy. The tax treatment of a loan depends on purpose, the benefit of a deduction depends on your income and the property’s cash flow, and the payoff depends on when you want to stop working. Change any one of those and the best order changes.
We built AeroWealth so you can see that interaction instead of guessing at it. Put the mortgage, the investment property, your super and your contributions into one plan, compare paying down the home against paying down the investment side by side, and stress test the rate and growth assumptions that could go wrong.
The aim is a deliberate choice: you know the retirement age, income and net worth each path produces under Australian rules, and you can adjust before you commit.
Aerowealth Team
FAQ
Is my home loan interest ever tax-deductible?
Not while you live in the home as your residence, because the money was used for a private purpose. If you later rent the home out, interest on that loan can become deductible for the period it produces income. If part of a loan funds an investment, that part can be deductible, with the rest apportioned.
Can a loan secured against my home have deductible interest?
Yes. The ATO looks at what the money was used for, not the security. If you borrow against your home to buy a rental property, the interest on that borrowing is generally deductible, as in the Zeb example in TD 93/13.
Should I put extra cash on my home loan or my investment loan?
The home loan is usually the more expensive debt after tax, because its interest is never deductible. The answer still depends on your marginal rate, the property’s cash flow, the offset position and your retirement timing. Compare the options as scenarios in your own plan, and see a licensed financial adviser for personal advice.
Does the 2026-27 negative gearing change affect existing investors?
According to the MFAA’s Budget summary, properties owned before 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 are grandfathered, so current rules continue to apply. The changes target established residential properties bought after that time, from 1 July 2027. Check the final legislation before relying on it.
Sources
- TD 93/13, ATO legal database
- Interest expenses, Australian Taxation Office
- TR 2000/2, deductibility of interest on moneys drawn under line of credit facilities and redraw facilities
- Using your home for rental or business, Australian Taxation Office
- Main residence determination 1012914579914, ATO legal database
- Federal Budget 2026-27, MFAA